The Israeli
Assault on Gaza is the Palestinian Kristalnacht
The Holocaust began in Germany on Kristalnacht when over 90 Jews were killed, more than
30,000 were arrested and sent to concentration camps (where over 1,000 died of mistreatment
before the remainder were released) thousands of Jewish shops, homes and
offices and more than 200 synagogues were destroyed in a government sanctioned
riot by brown shirt thugs.
This was in response to the murder in
Paris of a German diplomat Ernst von Rath who was
shot and killed by seventeen year old Herschel Grynszpan,
a Polish Jew. Grynszpan’s
parents emigrated from Poland to Hannover in Germany in 1911. After World War I they became Polish
citizens.
In March 1938 Poland passed a law depriving
Polish citizens of their citizenship who had lived continuously abroad for more
than five years: this was explicitly intended to prevent the 70,000 Polish Jews
living in Germany and Austria returning to Poland. In August 1938 the German authorities
announced that all residence permits for foreigners were being cancelled and
would have to be renewed: it was obvious that Jews would not be given new
permits. Poland, however, said that it
would not accept Jews of Polish origin after the end of October.
On October 26th, to beat this
deadline, the Gestapo was ordered to arrest and deport immediately all Polish
Jews in Germany.
The Grynszpans
were among the estimated 12,000 Polish Jews arrested, stripped of their
property and herded aboard trains headed for Poland. When they got to the border they were forced
to walk two kilometers to the Polish border town of Zbaszyn. There, however, Poland refused to admit
them. The Grynszpans
and thousands of other Polish-Jewish deportees were left stranded at the
border, fed only intermittently by the Polish Red Cross and Jewish welfare
organizations. It was from Zbaszyn that Herschel’s sister sent a post card asking for
him to send money.
Herschel, who was an illegal immigrant
living with his uncle in Paris, was so upset by the post card and the condition
of his family and other Jews that he took his last money, bought a gun and
killed Von Rath.
Now, let’s compare Herschel Grynszpan’s story to the story of the Palestinians in
Gaza. They were expelled from their
homes sixty years ago and have been living as stateless people on charity on
the border of Israel and Egypt, neither of which wants them; just like the
Polish Jews on the border with Poland seventy years ago. Repeated promises of statehood, freedom and
democracy have come to nothing. Even
Arabs living in Israel have second class rights.
Two years ago, Hamas came to power in a
democratic election. Israel, with the
full support of the Bush Administration, refused to recognize the results of
the election and collectively punished the Palestinians living in Gaza by closing
its borders and only permitting humanitarian supplies to enter because Hamas
refuses to recognize the legitimacy of the state of Israel.
Blockade is an act of war. It was the closing of the Straits of Tiran by
Egypt in 1967 that provided the excuse for Israel’s attack on the Arabs in the
Six Day War. So, when Israel is
blockaded it is legitimate self-defense for it to strike first at its
adversaries. That’s how Israel obtained
the Golan Heights, the West Bank and Gaza.
But when Gaza, the historical crossroads of the African and Asian
continents, is blockaded by Israel and Egypt and turned into a concentration
camp of stateless people, that is considered
legitimate self-defense by the neo-cons and right wing Israelis. This can be proved just by finding the Israels who really think the solution to the Palestinian
problem is to exterminate them.
So, Hamas and the Palestinians in Gaza
have dug some tunnels and built some rockets and fired them at Israel and they
have killed a few people, but mostly they have been a nuisance. Just as Germany planned Kristalnacht
long in advance and used the von Rath murder as an
excuse to unleash it, Israel planned the attack on Gaza months ago and just
seized on the excuse of the rockets to attack. So, Israel attacks Gaza, killing 1,285 people,
250 of whom are children, wounding 5,500, destroying $2 billion worth of mosques,
houses, businesses, and government buildings.
The Israelis lost 13 people, three civilians, and ten soldiers. Four of the soldiers were killed by Israeli
fire. So, basically the proportion was
1,000 dead and injured Palestinians for every dead Israeli.
Just as Herschel Grynszpan’s
act of violence was borne of systematic discrimination and oppression, the
response of Hamas and the Palestinians is the same. So, if Israel really wants peace (which it
doesn’t) it has to face the truth about the nature of the Jewish State and come
to terms with the people from whom they stole the land and are stealing the
water.
The one difference between the Israelis
and the Nazis is that even though their behaviors are identical, the Israelis
know what they did was wrong which is why they are now scrambling to protect
the commanders and officials from the possibility of arrest and prosecution abroad
for war crimes.
Israel’s attack on Gaza is a replay of Kristalnacht, down to the reason for it’s cause; and it’s
not going to go away because all the children who have lost limbs and been
traumatized are going to be around for decades to sue the Israeli government
for compensation. Like the Nazis,
Israel’s superior technological strength has enabled it to fight its way into
an untenable position. The reason for
this is that Israel’s army is a state within a state, it can fight, but it
can’t negotiate.
Return to Institute of Election Analysis Website